Movie Review on
Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio: A journey of love, life, death and acceptance
Released on November 11, 2022, Guillermo Del Toro’s
Pinocchio is a stop-motion animated movie directed by Guillermo Del
Toro and Mark Gustafsan. This movie has been nominated for multiple awards like
Oscar, BAFTA, Art Directors Guild, Golden Globes, and many more (more
information on awards can be found in this link). Based
in Italy, this movie is about Geppetto and his son, the handcrafted wooden boy
called Pinocchio. This movie represents the idea of knowing and accepting
someone as they are and loving them without having to change them in order to
meet societal expectations. It also shows the relationship between father and
son and the many ways in which this relationship is challenged, questioned,
explored, and at the end accepted and cherished. Geppetto is a gifted artist
and carpenter who lives in Italy during World War II with his son Carlo.
Geppetto loses his son to a bomb released by one of the airplanes returning to
base. Geppetto’s love, mourning, and grief for Carlo make him desperately find
Carlo’s presence in the boy that he carves out of a pinewood tree, named
Pinocchio. Geppetto’s creation of Pinocchio looks monstrous on the screen
through the shadows of him axing the tree in a scary way with Geppetto’s
grunting noises. This is much different than what he looks like when he is a
loving father to Carlo and “a model Italian citizen” (Pinocchio) to
society. Contrary to this calm, loving, and stable Geppetto, Pinocchio’s
creator looks unstable from being too drunk, filled with rage and impatience.
Given life by the Spirit, the wooden boy becomes Geppetto’s son Pinocchio. They
both have difficulty understanding each other. As Geppetto keeps searching for
Carlo in Pinocchio and Pinocchio finds it difficult to not stay true to
himself, they grow apart. In Pinocchio’s journey, he finds a friend and a companion
in a cricket called Sebastian J. Cricket and a monkey called Spazzatura.
Geppetto and Pinocchio’s love and understanding for each other grow over time.
Geppetto realizes that Pinocchio can never be Carlo and that he loves Pinocchio
despite that. The movie starts and ends in the same place with a closed shot of
the pinecone in the frame. The beginning scene has a morose and cold tone with
blue, and green colors on the screen. Whereas the end scene takes place in the
same setting but has a loving, hopeful, warm tone with colors like orange,
brown, and yellow. The trajectory from the beginning to the end of the movie
marks the loop of a journey in which life and death exist and coexist. The
journey from the coldness of the stories of the individual characters and the
coldness in their relationship to the growth and warmth of their
individualities and their relationships is traversed through the movie. The
growth in the characters is shown in raw, intimate, and non-linear ways. Along
with the other characters like Sebastian and Spazzatura, Geppetto goes through
such growth too.
Geppetto is a loving, caring, calm, and social being in the
beginning. But when he loses Carlo, he becomes impatient, drunk, and angry.
However, after Pinocchio comes into his life, he no longer wastes his nights
and days drinking and goes back to working again. But soon his angry,
impatient, and stubborn side shows up again when Pinocchio fails to be a real
boy. Slowly with time, as Geppetto realizes the love that he carries for Pinocchio,
his character grows into an understanding and loving father again. Geppetto is
a perfectionist too. From choosing the pinecone that looks perfect without any
of its scales missing to finishing the crucifix with perfection, he shows life
to his son Carlo the way Geppetto looks at life. But an artist who walks on the
marks of flawlessness and only carves perfect creations ends up building
Pinocchio without perfection. He starts off carving Pinocchio with perfect ears
and hair but leaves the precision unfinished from being too drunk, something
that Guillermo mentions in the documentary Guillermo Del Toro’s
Pinocchio: Handcarved Cinema. This unrefined, imperfect creation of
Geppetto becomes everything that he has a hard time accepting. This is one of
the reasons he keeps telling Pinocchio, “Carlo never acted like this” (Pinocchio).
Pinocchio is an outsider for both Geppetto and society because he does not fit
the mold of a real boy suited for civil society. Geppetto chooses to carve
Pinocchio in hopes of getting back his son Carlo, out of the pine tree that
grows from the pine that causes Carlo’s death (Carlo goes into the church to
get back the perfect pine that he found and at that moment bombs are dropped on
the church killing Carlo). From the bark of that tree starts a new story of
life, love, and family for Pinocchio, Geppetto, and Sebastian. A pine that
causes Carlo’s death, grows into a pine tree that gives birth to Pinocchio, who
changes the way the characters in the movie perceive life, death, love, and
relationships. Even though Pinocchio is made to revive Carlo, he is nothing
like Carlo.
Unlike Carlo, Pinocchio is not an obedient son who listens
to his father. Pinocchio questions things around him. He does not simply listen
to Geppetto or society because he is asked to do so. He tries to be like Carlo
when he gets to know how much Geppetto loves Carlo. He says “I will be just
like Carlo! I will obey and go to school, and I will be the very, very best at…
whatever they do there” (Pinocchio). Even though Pinocchio tries his
best to be like Carlo to receive Geppetto’s love, he fails at being anyone
other than himself. He is so pure that he remains true to himself and
ultimately teaches Geppetto to love him for who he really is. Pinocchio is
curious about why certain things are done in certain ways and why certain
standards are believed to be better than others. For example, he has a hard
time understanding why he is not accepted by society just because he is carved
out of wood, but the crucifix made out of wood is worshipped by the same
people. He questions and challenges the ideas of normalcy and fixated
standards. To others, he is an “abnormal boy” who “lacks discipline” (Pinocchio)
and is either compared to Carlo or Candlewick (the ideal representation of a
real boy, the son of a government official). It takes time for Geppetto to
understand that Pinocchio is a boy who has his own identity. This boy sees the
world through his own eyes and is “an independent thinker” (Pinocchio). But
society fails to see this in him. Pinocchio becomes a star in a carnival
organized by the antagonist Volpe. One of the reasons Pinocchio likes being the
star of the puppet show in the carnival is because he gets accepted, seen, and
loved by the audience for his show. From constantly being seen as just a wooden
boy and an outsider, Pinocchio gets appreciated and celebrated by the kids in
the carnival. This is the first time he gets to experience acceptance from
people around him since he was made by Geppetto. In the fight between Geppetto
and Volpe to claim Pinocchio as their own, Pinocchio comes under a car and
dies. That’s when the audience of the movie gets to know that Pinocchio does
not go through real death. His deaths are just “waiting periods” (Pinocchio).
He will die many times and will come back to life again. The audience also gets
to know that Pinocchio, for this very reason of not going through real death,
will never be able to become a real boy like Carlo. This is Guillermo’s way of
letting his audience know that transforming Pinocchio into a real boy is not
what this movie is about. After his first death, Pinocchio becomes more
convinced that he cannot become like Carlo, and he does not want to become like
Carlo. It is as if he takes a new birth and does not want to pretend to be
Carlo or force himself to be like Carlo to receive his father’s love. For the
first time, he lets his father know “I’m not Carlo. I don’t want to be like
Carlo” (Pinocchio). In a moment of rage and agony, Geppetto lashes out
at Pinocchio calling him a burden. Pinocchio shows his love for his father in
his own way by trying to unburden him of his worries. From here onwards
Geppetto’s understanding of his love for Pinocchio for who he really is starts.
Sebastian J. Cricket, a person of wisdom and knowledge, helps Geppetto in
seeing what Geppetto could not see all the while Pinocchio was with him, which
is Pinocchio’s love for Geppetto. Sebastian says, “Why are you so blind? So
absolutely blind! The boy loves you. He has much to learn but he loves you for
who you are. Would it kill you to do as much for him?” (Pinocchio).
Geppetto not only recognizes Pinocchio’s love for him but also recognizes his
love for Pinocchio. He searches for Pinocchio and in that search, he gets
swallowed by a monstrous-sized dogfish.
This dogfish is a metaphor for the size of the obstacle that
both Geppetto and Pinocchio must cross to find each other again. The
uncomfortable slimy gut full of mucous inside the dogfish represents the
unpleasant emotions and situations that they have to go through to understand
each other. Pinocchio’s nose acts as a bridge that saves Geppetto, Sebastian,
and Spazzatura to escape from the dogfish, which symbolizes the gap that they
have covered through understanding, support, and care, in order to reach out to
each other and help each other in coming out of the unpleasantness of their
relationships. Even though Pinocchio is not seen or accepted as a real boy and
is looked at as a wooden boy in the movie, he helps other characters in the movie
to come to terms with their emotions, accept their emotions and be
compassionate of others’ emotions. In an interview from the documentary Guillermo
Del Toro’s Pinocchio: Handcarved Cinema, Guillermo mentions Pinocchio
is “really good at being natural, but he is incredibly intimate when he’s
whispering or talking to the cricket or talking to Candlewick. There is an
absolute pure emotion there.” The pure emotion and the intimate side that
Guillermo includes in Pinocchio reflect that he does not need to be a real boy
to feel emotions or to share intimate and meaningful relationships. It also
represents that it is not Pinocchio who needs to change in order to be in the
society, but it is the society that needs to change its constricted perspective
in order to recognize the purity of Pinocchio’s character. This becomes clear
when Guillermo expresses his motive for making this film in the documentary. He
says, “Normally Pinocchio is about what Pinocchio learns in the world and then
becomes a good boy and therefore becomes a real boy, and our Pinocchio is not
that. He changes everyone because he is so pure. He changes Geppetto. He
changes the cricket. He changes Spazzatura. He changes everyone” (Guillermo
Del Toro’s Pinocchio: Handcarved Cinema). Pinocchio, who does not even
understand the meaning of death in the beginning, teaches the characters like
Geppetto, Sebastian, Candlewick, and Spazzatura the meaning of life, family,
father-son relationship, and the depth of loss and love. Throughout the movie
and especially by the end of the movie, Guillermo makes it clearer that the
motive of this movie is not to force Pinocchio into the mold of a real boy but
to let others accept him as he is and for Pinocchio to grasp the meaning of
love, life, and death. Pinocchio becomes a source of support, comfort, and care
for characters like Geppetto, Sebastian, Candlewick, and Spazzatura.
Geppetto realizes his love for Pinocchio and Pinocchio’s
love for him, despite the difference that Pinocchio and Carlo have. He
literally crosses a sea to see Pinocchio again, survives the monstrous attack
of the dogfish, and learns to accept Pinocchio the way he is. At one point,
when he almost loses Pinocchio he says, “I was trying to make you someone you
are not. So don’t be Carlo or anyone else. Be exactly who you are. I… I love
you exactly as you are” (Pinocchio). Guillermo beautifully captures the
moment when Geppetto and Pinocchio accept each other as they are and express
their love for each other in front of the vast sea and the purplish sky with a
hint of orange from the rising sun in the background. The frame is filled with
Sebastian, Spazzatura, Pinocchio, and Geppetto, and the warmth of their embrace
and laughter becomes as bright as the warm orange sun. Sebastian also goes
through growth in his character while being with Pinocchio. Sebastian, a
writer, traveler, scholar, and a person who lived with artists learns to come
out of his own world, write a memoir that does not only involve him but the
people around him too, and uses his wisdom to guide and save Pinocchio in his
journey of adjusting to the human world. Candlewick, a young boy who is groomed
to be a soldier in war by his father Podesta and who tries his best to match
his father’s unreasonable expectations, learns to feel his emotions without
guilt with the help of Pinocchio. He learns that he is allowed to feel scared
or sad and does not have to compete against people to deserve his father’s love
or to be accepted by his father as a son. What starts as a competitive
relationship between Pinocchio and Candlewick shapes up into a loving
friendship. Candlewick gathers the courage to revolt against his father for
himself and for his friend Pinocchio. From not liking Pinocchio and competing
against him for Volpe’s attention and admiration, Spazzatura too becomes
Pinocchio’s friend and stays with him till his last breath. Both Candlewick and
Spazzatura are loved and cared for by Pinocchio without asking for anything in
return or without boxing them into categories of useless sons or unwanted beings.
For the first time in their life, they experience genuine comfort, friendship,
and love in Pinocchio’s presence, and like good and loyal friends they return
the same to Pinocchio. This enables them to revolt against Podesta and Volpe
and break free from the positions that force them into believing that they are
inferior.
Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio is not just a
movie about a father and son, but also an emotional journey of a boy who is
forced to feel lost in the world that demands him to change. It is a vulnerable
response to a society that cannot conceive of anything but perfection and
constricted perspectives about humans and relationships. It challenges the
stereotyped boxes of real, ideal, and perfect. It also questions the connection
between never feeling scared or vulnerable and courage or strength. Through
Pinocchio’s dialogues with Candlewick, Guillermo is saying that showing
vulnerability is not an antonym for courage or strength. This movie will touch
those hearts who deny settling with the roles that this society fixes for them.
There are moments that are so profoundly meaningful that I had to pause the
movie and think about what it means to be a human and what it takes to be a
human. It is like a fresh breath of air in a world that requires a pure and
free soul like Pinocchio to remain stuck in a place or role that suffocates
him. I feel that this movie can be an inspiration for writers, directors,
animators, and voice artists to present stories, characters, and themes that
reach the audience in a way where they feel heard, seen, and understood. I also
think that watching the documentary, Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio:
Handcarved Cinema, on the making of the film after watching the movie will
be insightful in understanding the motive of the movie because it gives a
glimpse of the world of stop-motion and the way this movie is visualized,
conceptualized and seen by the artists who created it. For me, Guillermo
Del Toro’s Pinocchio is a movie that I can go back to when life gets
too difficult to understand and I can take refuge in the soothing and
comforting dialogues of the movie. Whenever I feel like my creative juice is
running out, I can replenish myself by watching the beautiful story and vision
that this movie creates.
Few quotes from Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio that
stayed with me:
“Well, in this world you get what you give.”
“I’ll try my best and that’s the best anyone can do.”
“What’s a burden?” “It’s something painful you must carry even though it hurts you very much.”
“But little did I know that death was not the end.”
“Every moment you shared with them may be the very last. You never know how long you have with someone until they are gone.”
“I only wished to bring you joy.” “And you did, you did bring me joy. Such terrible, terrible joy.”
“I was trying to make you someone you are not. So don’t be Carlo or anyone else. Be exactly who you are. I… I love exactly as you are.”
“What happens, happens. And then, we are gone.”
Works Cited
Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio. Directed by Guillermo Del Toro and Mark Gustafsan,
Netflix, 2022.
Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio:
Handcarved Cinema, Netflix,
2022.
“Guillermo Del Toro’s Pinocchio 2022: Awards”, IMDb, https://m.imdb.com/title/tt1488589/awards/?ref_=tt_awd.
